By Manish
When Maria Rodriguez opened her family grocery store in downtown Phoenix fifteen years ago, she never imagined that trade policy would become her biggest business challenge. Like thousands of small grocery store owners across America, Maria is discovering that tariffs don't affect all retailers equally. While large chains have teams of economists and supply chain experts to navigate trade disruptions, small businesses like hers are fighting an uphill battle that threatens their very survival.
The numbers tell a stark story. According to the American Action Forum, small businesses across the United States are facing approximately $85 billion in direct tariff costs annually. But this figure only scratches the surface of the real impact on family-owned grocery stores and independent retailers who form the backbone of American communities.
The Unequal Burden of Trade Wars
Small businesses employ nearly half of America's workforce, yet they bear a disproportionate burden when it comes to tariffs. The National Retail Federation reports that 98 percent of retailers are small businesses, supporting over 13 million jobs nationwide. These aren't just statistics – they represent real families and communities that depend on the success of local businesses.
The challenge for small grocery stores is multifaceted. Unlike major chains that can leverage their purchasing power to negotiate better deals with suppliers or absorb temporary cost increases, small retailers operate on razor-thin margins with limited financial cushions. When tariffs drive up the cost of imported goods – from aluminum cans to packaging materials to specialty food items – these costs flow directly to the bottom line.
Ben Knepler, founder of True Places, an outdoor utility chair company in Pennsylvania, captures the essence of this struggle perfectly. "Uncertainty is like kryptonite to a business," he explains. "You can't make any kind of investment decision when you don't know what the world is going to look like tomorrow." This uncertainty is particularly devastating for small grocery stores that must plan their inventory six to nine months in advance to meet seasonal demand.
When Every Dollar Counts
The financial pressure on small businesses has reached a breaking point. Recent employment data from the ADP National Employment Report shows that private employment among small businesses declined by 60,000 in September 2025 alone. This marks the fifth consecutive monthly decline for businesses with certain employee ranges, painting a troubling picture of an entire sector under stress.
For grocery store owners like Maria, these aren't abstract economic indicators – they represent difficult decisions about whether to lay off longtime employees or reduce store hours. The ripple effects extend far beyond the store itself, impacting suppliers, delivery drivers, and the broader community that depends on these local businesses.
Ross Harrow, owner of The Flour Shop, a California bakery known for its specialty cakes, describes how tariff costs cascade through the supply chain. "My suppliers pay those taxes upfront, and they pass that cost along to me," he says. "That forces me to completely rework my margins and product pricing." For small grocery stores carrying hundreds or thousands of products, this constant repricing becomes a full-time job that takes away from serving customers and growing the business.
The Innovation Penalty
Perhaps most troubling is how tariffs are stifling the entrepreneurial spirit that has long defined American small business. Knepler believes these policies are undermining the very essence of American innovation because tariffs force businesses to focus on survival rather than growth and innovation. "When people think of America, they think of innovation and entrepreneurial spirit," he says. "But these policies are literally undermining the very essence of what it means to be an American business owner."
This innovation penalty is particularly acute for small grocery stores trying to differentiate themselves from large chains. Many independent grocers have built their reputations on offering unique products, supporting local suppliers, or providing specialized services that big box stores cannot match. When tariffs force them to focus solely on managing costs and maintaining cash flow, they lose the ability to invest in the very innovations that make them competitive.
The Supply Chain Reality
One of the most persistent myths about tariffs is that they will encourage domestic production and reduce dependence on foreign suppliers. The reality for small grocery stores is far more complex. Jared Hendricks, who runs Village Lighting Company in Utah, points out a fundamental flaw in this thinking. "I'm never going to happen in the USA. My factory can't be here," he says, noting that over 200 people work in multiple overseas factories creating the component parts for his products.
This reality extends to grocery stores in countless ways. Specialty food items, packaging materials, display equipment, and even basic supplies often come from global supply chains that have been developed over decades. The idea that small grocery stores can simply switch to domestic suppliers ignores the complex realities of modern retail operations.
Moreover, even when domestic alternatives exist, small stores lack the purchasing power to make these switches economically viable. A large chain might be able to negotiate favorable terms with a new domestic supplier, but a small grocery store ordering a fraction of the volume faces much higher per-unit costs.
The Community Cost
The impact of tariffs on small grocery stores extends far beyond the businesses themselves. These stores often serve as community anchors, providing not just goods and services but also employment opportunities and social connections that bind neighborhoods together. When a family grocery store closes, the effects ripple through the entire community.
Dewar Gaines of Gaines Family Farmstead, a pet treat company in Alabama, understands this interconnectedness well. He worries about how tariffs affect the retail partners who sell his products. "Around 40 to 50 percent of pet products sold in the U.S. are sourced overseas. When tariffs hit, shelves go empty. That affects their ability to operate, and at scale, it affects us too."
This interconnectedness means that the failure of small grocery stores has multiplier effects throughout the local economy. Every store closure means lost jobs not just for the store employees, but also for local suppliers, delivery drivers, and service providers who depend on these businesses.
A Call for Recognition
As policymakers continue to debate trade policy, it's crucial that they understand the real-world impact on small businesses. Gaines hopes lawmakers will take a broader view when crafting trade policy. "I hope policymakers consider more than just the immediate revenue from tariffs," he says. "They need to think about the long-term impact on small businesses and the broader economy."
The data supports his concern. With small businesses facing $85 billion in direct tariff costs and employment declining for five consecutive months, the evidence suggests that current trade policies are having the opposite of their intended effect. Rather than strengthening American businesses, they may be weakening the very enterprises that employ nearly half of American workers.
For small grocery store owners like Maria Rodriguez, the solution isn't necessarily the elimination of all trade policies, but rather a more nuanced approach that recognizes the different impacts on different types of businesses. Small businesses need predictability, not just protection. They need policies that help them compete, not just survive.
As we continue to debate the role of tariffs in American economic policy, we must remember that behind every statistic is a real business owner, real employees, and real communities that depend on the success of these enterprises. The future of American retail – and American communities – may well depend on getting this balance right.
Grocery Store Jobs